Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **NZF** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 3:41 pm

Top 35 as of right now,

1. Gagne
2. Rivera
3. Lidge
4. K-Rod
5. Foulke
6. Nathan
7. Wagner
8. Benetiz
9. Hoffman
10. Izzy
11. F.Codero
12. Dotel
13. Guardado
14. Kolb
15. Percival
16. Mota
17. Takatsu
18. BJ Ryan
19. Hawkins
20. Looper
21. Baez
22. Batista
23. Wickman
24. Graves
25. C.Cordero
26. Mesa
27. Valverde
28. MacDougal
29. Urbina
30. Ayala
31. Aquino
32. Julio
33. Borowski
34. Speier
35. Chacon

by **trevisc** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 3:49 pm

My top 10:

1. Rivera
2. Gagne
3. K-Rod
4. Lidge
5. Foulke
6. Wagner
7. Guardado
8. Izzy
9. F.Cordero
7. Benitez
8. Mota
9. Kolb
10. Nathan

by **rockchalk** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 3:56 pm

MacDougal won't be closing in KC to start the year. It will be Affeldt and unless he implodes he should hang on to the job for at least this year.

I wouldn't change the rank any, but just the player. Affeldt has nasty stuff, but I'm not sure he's got the makeup. Besides, how many leads are the Royals going to have to save anyway?

by **XTSilver** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 3:59 pm

trev did you forget dotel or purposely leave him out of your top 10?

by **trevisc** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:01 pm

XTSilver wrote:trev did you forget dotel or purposely leave him out of your top 10?

I purposely left him out. Without Mulder and Hudson the A's aren't gonna give him too many save opportunities. I'd say he'll be lucky to break 30

by **XTSilver** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:08 pm

How bad do you really think the A's will be without Hudson and Mulder?
By my count there wer 5 closers last year over 30 saves on teams with sub .500 records. I don't believe the A's will be a sub .500 team next year and therefore because they have a proven closer with great stuff I believe it would be extremely unlucky if he did not get 30.

But hey to each his own.

by **raiders_umpire** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:09 pm

my top 10....

1a gagne
1b rivera
2 lidge
3 foulke
4 k rod
5 wagner
6 izzy
7 cordero
8 kolb
9 benitez
10 nathan

by **Cornbread Maxwell** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:10 pm

hats a pretty solid list NZF - thanks - I really wouldnt change too much

by **J35J** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:11 pm

Here is my top 25

1 E. Gagne
2 B. Lidge
3 F. Rodriguez
4 B. Wagner
5 M. Rivera
6 K. Foulke
7 J. Nathan
8 J. Isringhausen
9 T. Hoffman
10 A. Benitez
11 O. Dotel
12 F. Cordero
13 D. Kolb
14 T. Percival
15 D. Graves
16 G. Mota
17 B. Looper
18 B. J. Ryan
19 D. Baez
20 J. Mesa
21 C. Cordero
22 G. Aquino
23 J. Affledt
24 E. Guardado
25 B. Wickman

Jason

by **Cornbread Maxwell** » Wed Dec 29, 2004 4:12 pm

J3J5 - that seems very very low for Guardado and Wickman - why?

Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

Closer rankings

Closer rankings

Who is online