Top 5 3b prospects

[Rico The Retard]

Who are your guys top 5 3rd base prospects

[Savoy Special]

I would have to go with:

Andy Marte
Ian Stewart
Garrett Atkins
Dallas McPherson
Edwin Encarnacion
Eric Duncan
Corey Hart

[ghostfacek]

Andy Marte
Ian Stewart
Dallas Mcpherson
Eric Duncan
Billy Butler

[oakiedragon]

I would put the top 3 in this order:
1.Marte
2.McPherson
3. Kinsler
Marte is a stud but he is still raw, he's projected by some to hit 50+ Hr in his prime. Kinsler is also still too raw to tell exactly but he hit 30 hr this year and I dont see why he wont continue, plus hes going to play in Coors which isnt bad for anyones stats, minus pitchers. McPherson is the most ML ready and he'll start at 3b next year. I think he has a great chance b/c he's going to be thrown into a very potent lineup with lots of rbi potential. All three are pretty much locks imo.

[ensanimal]

kinsler plays ss/2b and plays for the rangers. methinks you were talking about ian stewart, who is my #1 3b prospect.

stewart
mcpherson
marte
encarnacion

atkins won't be at 3b for very much longer.

[Savoy Special]

so what will happen to Duncan if/when he goes to the Dodgers?

[oakiedragon]

youre right i was talking about stewart. My bad. was looking at a trade earlier for kinsler and had it on my mind. Thanks for the correction.

[Jivedude]

Andy Marte
Ian Stewart
Dallas Mcpherson
Edwin Encarnacion
Nate Schierholtz

[hybrid]

1) Andy Marte - obvious #1
2) Ian Stewart - plays for the rockies, enough said
3) Dallas McPherson - not as high on him as some, but I'll stick him here for now
4) Joel Guzman - I'm sure a few will notice he is playing SS right now. But he is already quite a big guy and no one really sees him staying there, especially with the departure of Beltre. I could have him higher, but since he is more raw I'll keep him at #4 .... but he could rival anyone on the list for being the best in the future.
5) Eric Duncan - could be on the verge of having a break out year, power wise

[trevisc]

Marte
McP
Hart
Stewart
Atkins