TOP 10 FANTASY PLAYERS THIS YEAR OVERALL??

[Super GM]

J.D. Drew (no love for J.D.!!!!??)
Manny Ramirez
David Ortiz
Aord
Johan Santana
Ben Sheets
Sean Casey
Albert Pujols
Vlad
Abreu

[NZF]

No way Casey can be in there ahead of Helton nor JD drew ahead of Bonds. Sheets and Santana ahead of Schmidt either for that matter.

I thought we would get more discussion around the current Top 10.
For God's sake, someone pick my list to bits will you

[raiders_umpire]

Standard roto

Pujols
Vlad
Schmidt *
Bonds
Helton
Abreu *
Rolen *
A-Rod
Manny
Randy J *

looks about right to me with the names...might have moved manny up a couple of spots and helton down a few...but overall names looks good to me....

[Tavish]

Where's all the Gagne praise?

[bkholla]

NO way ortiz is not in the top 10


Bletran and A-rod are over rated

[kentx12]

Where's all the Gagne praise?

Intresting thoughts on alot of these names but I just dont see how any closer can be a top 10 pick.

[ensanimal]

where is tejada on these lists. top offensive numbers, plus at ss. should be top 10 for this year so far i'd say.

[Tavish]

Where's all the Gagne praise?

Intresting thoughts on alot of these names but I just dont see how any closer can be a top 10 pick.

I was surprised by how many people out there thought so too. Either they haven't seen this thread yet or they changed their minds midseason.

[NZF]

I agree that there is a strong case to include both Tejada and Ortiz in a Top 10, but for me they are 11 and 12 respectively.

SS position scarcity is not the problem it was a year or two ago.

In fact 2B is now the only position that lacks any depth which is why I assume Slomo rated Soriano as still a Top 10 guy.

[Rico The Retard]

I would take these guys and there all off the top of my head

Bobby Abreu
Randy Johnson
Vladmir Guerrero
Jason Schmidt
Albert Pujols
Alex Rodriguez
Mark Mulder
Johan Santana
Scott Rolen
Carlos Beltran