Baseballer02 wrote:Edgar is one of the greatest DHs ever, but I just don't see him going into the HOF.
This is a sentence that will get us here in seattle pretty lit up. How can you say that he is one of the greatest (although i could argue greatest) at his position ever. And then turn around in the same sentence and say he doesn't go to the hall.
If in fact he is the greatest at his position. how can you not send him.
how can you not send him? esy, look at the numbers. they're very good, but not hof material. there's nothing spectacular there.
would you vote Galarraga into the hof? prolly not right (I would, cuz he's my fav). looking at the numbers though, they're very similar, plus the big cat has 2 gold gloves.
i know that's just one comparison, but, with those numbers i don't think he deserves to get in.