V. Zambrano vs Brett Myers

[DaQ]

For the rest of the season, who would you rather want?

Myers is an up-and-down SP who did great yesterday while Zambrano has great potential, but gives up a lot of walks? Both have rather high ERA's.

I don't know if Peterson can fix Zambrano's pitching problems this year but if he does. it'll be gold.

[FatGuyWithAMullet]

Myers has a much higher upside than Zambrano. However as you stated, Myers is very inconsistant and underperforming a majority of the time.

Personally I would rather have Myers for the simple reason that they are comparable in every typical 5X5 category but Myers is on a much better overall team so you would assume he would come up on top in the W category.

Contrary to popular belief, Peterson is not a pitching coach god, nor will he magically fix Zambrano's problems in "5 minutes" as he stated.

I'd go with Myers strictly on potential.