Any opinions on what the long-term resolution is here? I think its pretty clear that Hairston is a better hitter, better OBP, etc. Not sure of Roberts has a defensive advantage. However, with Gibbons coming back, I think it is decision time for the O's pretty soon.
I ask this becasue I am about to move Chad Cordero for Hairston. It's a keeper league, but I need steals and Avg now, not saves. So I am interested in whether or not Hairston will get regualr PT this season as the OF becomes more crowded, and whether he will bump out Roberts at 2B over the off-season.
My guess would be that the O's stick with Roberts at 2nd, and I would recommend you do too. Roberts has been hitting better than Hairston over the last month, and, more importantly for your needs, has been stealing more bases too:
I don't follow the Orioles much at all, so don't have any other insight to offer. Perhaps someone closer to the situation might be able to tell you more about who will get the ABs for the rest of the season.
"The game has a cleanness. If you do a good job, the numbers say so. You don't have to ask anyone or play politics. You don't have to wait for the reviews." - Sandy Koufax
Hairston yesterday stole his first base since June. Perhaps that was because of a litany of little niggling injuries (strained hammy, ran into a wall, fouled a ball off his knee, etc), but it's unclear whether that marks a return to his old running game.
He'll continue to play, but mostly as CF and DH ... Roberts is the 2b for the rest of this season.
now that matos is shelved for the remainder of the year, hairston is going to be a staple in the OF (primarily center). Gibbons is going to gradually work back into the starting job in right, pushing the horrific karummy garcia back to the bench where he belongs.
In terms of value over the rest of the year, mazilli seems very committed to b-rob as his leadoff guy (intermittent lineup changes last for only a day with him) and he is going to remain aggressive on the basepaths since the O's have nothing to play for but pride. I personally like roberts over hairston, only for the SB's....if you want a more consistent OBP guy then hairston is absoutely your guy but he is not going to run as much, particularly because he is entrenched in the bottom half of the lineup.
Actually, Mazzilli's still been playing around with it. He seems unsure whether to go with the guy who runs better, but also hits for a low average (though he has a marginally good OBP and fouls off many pitches), or to the man who's been hitting better this season (with less speed). Check out the game logs...Hairston was given a short leadoff stint. If Roberts struggles, look for Jerry.
Objectively, I'd rather have Chad Cordero. By a decent margin, too. In addition, Roberts won't give you AVG. Hairston may give you both, but isn't the greatest basestealer. His average is decent, but certainly not the best. Can you swing a deal or something?
Hall of Fame Hero
Joined: 27 May 2003
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: The empty seat next to the Tampa Bay heckler