Marquis or O. Hernandez?

[Bourne]

Who will be better for the rest of the 2004 season?
Marquis or O. Hernandez?

[perlick29]

I say El Duque. He is a risk to get hurt, but then again, who isn't this year? You know he'll almost always have good run support.

Marquis is a good candidate for a second half fade.

[Rohan]

When Mussina comes back where does that put Hernandez, on the bench?

[Surfs up]

I like Hernendez. The Yankees haven't had their whole rotation since the beginng of the season. He pitched pretty well tonight. Whereas Marquis lost. Marquis probably safer because he is already a starter.