Who would you rather have?

[TriplePlay]

Standard 5x5 head to head league. Whose more valuable?


Dye
Patterson
Hunter

[mikcou]

Id go with Patterson or Dye

[TDS-MN]

Huh, I have had them all at one point this year. Currently still have only Dye.

I'd probably rank Dye and Hunter as about even. Dye has the advantage in power, but I think Hunter will be more consistent, and hits the occasional HR.
I will admit that I don't know that much about Patterson, but he was really struggling early, and did NOTHING when I had him, except get moved way down in the batting order. Have not kept up on what he's done since.

[slomo007]

Patterson has the most upside, if that helps.

[Bukoski77]

I agree with slomo007.

Patterson has the most 5 tool ability and is in the best lineup.

[thetongueofire]

Patterson... hes shown somewhat better patience this year (hes already "smashed" his career high in walks) and the Cubbies need left handed hitters in there to sorta protect Sosa, Alou, Ramirez, Lee. he should also steal a lil more now that hes overcome his torn ACL. plus theres a chance that he could hit right in front of Sosa if he shows some more maturity as a hitter and/or Ordonez doesnt do well.

[SaintsOfTheDiamond]

I agree with slomo007.

Patterson has the most 5 tool ability and is in the best lineup.

I agree.