Casey or Bagwell

[Sp_Da_Man]

Which 1B has the better second half & why?

[slomo007]

It sounds like Casey will be activated immediately after the ASB, so assuming he can stay healthy and his injury doesn't linger, I'll say him.

Bagwell's shoulder I think is finally catching up to him at the plate.

[CrazyPooja90]

Much to my misfortune and disliking, Baggy's shoulder is crap. He has lost almost all his power and he fights to keep his average about the cellar.

And it will probably only get worse.

[DMXdawg]

Bagwell's shoulder makes him useless, stay with the healthier casey

[GoJaysGo]

i never thought i would hear somebody more injury prone then casey, he is always injured.

[tmoney]

I probably dont have many people who agree with me, but I would go with Bagwell. I think he will have a huge second half, its just one of those gut instincts I guess.