I like to give the edge to starters over relievers in most cases like this, and I'd take Wolf over Lidge. There are relivers who put up similar ratios to Lidge, just that they aren't closers, so they don't contribute in saves.
Since this is the case, I'd rather take Wolf, who is largely considered to be a pretty solid, about #3 fantasy starter, when healthy who can eat up innings and maintain solid ratios and pick up wins and strikeouts. This type of starter is, in my opinion, either rarer or more valuable than a lights out closer, as saves aren't overly hard to come by with Graves and Cordero(s) and Mesa showing that this year.
[quote:4fef447375="Geek"]The odds of the AL MVP coming from the American League are looking pretty good.[/quote]