Rank these SSs

[leafz17]

Tejada
Nomar
Young
Renteria
Jeter

[kaz]

Nomar
Miggy
DJ
Young
Renteria

[G-Man]

tejada i believe has had the best 1st half of his career, so one can only imagine what he has in store for his historically torrid 2nd half production this year.

sorry to skew the original question but where would everyone rank ROLLINS amongst the guys listed for the 2nd half?

[Amazinz]

sorry to skew the original question but where would everyone rank ROLLINS amongst the guys listed for the 2nd half?

I would take all five of those guys before Rollins.

[ajgnydc722]

For the 2nd half:

1. Tejada
2. Jeter
3. Garciaparra
4. Renteria
5. Young

Overall:

1. Tejada
2. Garciaparra
3. Jeter
4. Renteria
5. Young

[tmoney]

Tejada
Nomar
Renteria
Jeter
Young

And I would rank Rollins below all of them.

[ajgnydc722]

sorry to skew the original question but where would everyone rank ROLLINS amongst the guys listed for the 2nd half?

I would take all five of those guys before Rollins.

I agree.

[Ridgerunner]

As far as overall baseball ability.....
A-Rod ( he's still the best SS in the game!)
Tejada
Young
Garciaparra
Jeter
Renteria
Furcal
Uribe

RR

[wrveres]

actually I am kinda surpirised this didn't get heated ...

It usually does ... This whole "Who is the best SS" thingee ...

here, I'll give it bump

[thehat]

Pre-season, I rated the top SS as ARod, Tejada, Renteria in that order. I'll stay with the same order, as I believe you'll see a finally healthy Renteria begin to really rev it up.

Jeter, Nomar and Young after that. Garciaparra is a health risk to a bit of an extent, isn't he? And I think Young has the best chance of fading.