You opinions on Helton vs Giambi

[dannahann]

In my keeper league, we only protect 2 established hitters, a coner IF and an OF. Helton has been my corner IF, but I'm thinking of offering him in a package where I would receive Jason Giambi. Who do you guys think will be more valuable over the next few seasons??? 12 Team 6x6 (R, RBI, HR, SB, AVG, OPS) H2H.

[Arlo]

I think Helton's production will be better over the long run, although Giambi is obviously no slouch either. Their values are pretty similar this year, but Helton is younger and has Coors on his side.

[Jorge]

If you're a Helton owner you better pray that he doesnt get traded out of Coors. Giambi is a solid performer playing on a team with great players. I would go for Helton @ Home and Giambi @ Anywhere. So the edge goes to Giambi.