ajgnydc722 wrote: New Zealand Fan wrote: ajgnydc722 wrote:
New Zealand Fan wrote:Beckett
Not sure how that makes any sense whatsoever.
The fact Beckett is ranked top or that Santana is last ?
Beckett is always hurt and hasn't really proved too much. Santana hasn't either but he's stayed healthy so far (knock on wood) and has proved to be a dominating pitcher when he's on. No possible way Sheets can be ranked above Santana IMO. Even Oswalt is too low.
with all due respect, I don't really buy your argument.
You don't give Beckett his due credit because he has injury problems, and yet you say Oswalt is ranked too low. Oswalt, however, has had his own injury concerns, which are worth noting.
I realize that Santana seems to be the sexy pick at the moment after his three great outings, but let's keep the entire season in perspective. He hasn't been healthy all year, so he isn't always dominant. I think it is fair to say that most of these guys on the list are dominant when healthy and when he's on, so to say that about Santana does not make him stand out.
I don't know much about Sheets, so I can't really compare him to the others.