I would go with Ryno as well. As for Mattingly, I am a Yankee fan and a huge Donnie Baseball fan but I have to disagree. He shouldn't be in. While he fits my criteria for being the best at his position for a time, that time wasn't long enough because of injury. Blame it on the back. I look at it like I look at Koufax in the best pitcher ever discussion. The body of work just isn't long enough, IMHO.