I have him, and considered posting a thread about this in the bench/start forum (where this thread really ought to be, but I won't get into that, as I would tend to agree with any who happened to complain about constantly jumping from forum to forum etc. Trades/Waivers being separate is sweet, but bench/start, and game cheering and venting... what's left for this forum? Ok, strike all of that from the record, I'll deal.) Anyhow... As I was saying, I probably would lean towards benching him.
I don't like to start pitchers from whom I realistically can't know what to expect. I think only getting four innings in against the Mets is a little bit discouraging, even though they weren't poorly pitched by any means , it's just that the fewer the innings. the less the chance for the win. He'll probably get several Ks, and maybe he'll keep the Indians lineup in check, or maybe he'll get lit up. It really could go either way. I'm not comfortable with the possibility of a 6ER performance and an early inning exit, and there's no reason in my mind to rule that out as a realistic possibility.