It looks pretty close to me. Tejada has been amazing, and Randa is underrated, but Lowe's performance will be missed. AirTimid's point that he may tail off somewhat is worth considering, although Lowe's pitch counts haven't been terribly high so far. At any rate, Burnett makes for a nice replacement. If your h2h scoring isn't terribly skewed toward starting pitching, I'd accept this offer. Helton's performance should more than make up for what you lose. The shallower the league, the more important the true stars become, and Helton is one of the best.