Who will have the worst year?

[Liberty30]

Three middle tier shortstops, who will have the worst rest of the season?

Angel Berroa
Bobby Crosby
Kaz Matsui


If you don't want to comment, feel free to vote.

[slomo007]

Haha, I see you're still struggling with this dilemma huh?

I dropped Crosby (think I told you this already), and kept Berroa. So far so good, I got credit for Crosby's 2 HR day.

I think you can't really go wrong with any of those guys, they will all have good/solid years. I think by the end of the year it won't really matter who you kept/dropped.

Crosby has more upside than any of them IMO. I voted for Berroa though because I don't think he'll match last year's production, but he'll still be good. KC as a whole has been cold lately, so I hope they can turn it around.

[Liberty30]

Haha, I see you're still struggling with this dilemma huh?

I dropped Crosby (think I told you this already), and kept Berroa. So far so good, I got credit for Crosby's 2 HR day.

I think you can't really go wrong with any of those guys, they will all have good/solid years. I think by the end of the year it won't really matter who you kept/dropped.

Crosby has more upside than any of them IMO. I voted for Berroa though because I don't think he'll match last year's production, but he'll still be good. KC as a whole has been cold lately, so I hope they can turn it around.

Yeah, still mulling it over.

Everytime I think I've decided something happens to change my mind. I think, barring an unforeseen event in the immediate future that I'll go with Angel.

<-- Me

Thanks for the help Slomo

[slomo007]

No problem....I was in the same situation, and had Crosby, Berroa, and now Rollins.

I needed to keep two, and Rollins won a spot for his steals....dropped Crosby but am now thinking maybe that was a mistake. If Crosby's 2 homer day would have been a day sooner, not sure what I would have done. If he makes it through waivers, I am going to consider dropping Berroa for him.

Good luck with it, let me know what you do....

[jpbusta]

Kaz shouldn't be in that list. He'll become one of the top 5 ss after this year. Between crosby and berroa. Berroa's more likely to have a better season because he's already somewhat proven himself in the big leagues last year. On the other hand, Crosby was great in the minors, but it's his first year. I'd imagine crosby hit a few more homeruns, but berroa will have more runs, rbis, sbs, and a better ba.

[nmarq8]

i don't know, that's a tough call...all i'm gonna say is that i used a mid-round pick on berroa, waited through his stint on the DL, and i haven't been to happy about things. i just picked up jack wilson because he's been hot and benched berroa, i still think he's got something to prove in the 2nd half of the season. i have a lot more respect, however, for crosby's future rather than berroa's.