Utely vs Durham, who would YOU rather have??

[Fender1114]

Durham is more established, but an injury nightmare. Utley is playing well, but he may lose playing time wonce Placido returns. What do you guys think??

[DaQ]

If Utley stays in the Majors, the answer is easy. If not, I suppose Durham is better sicne he'll actually be playing.

[rlee]

I traded Soriano last week (for Schilling and Guillen) and have been trolling for a 2B. I just dropped Mackowiak for Utley. He's been hot and hope he's starting to live up to his minor league hype.

I have never been big on Durham. His durability and production the last two years have been awful.

[Crazy Horse]

I'd stay with Utley until the Phils decide what to do when Polanco gets back. Who else is out there besides Durham? There;s gotta be somebody else, right?