Team A: P Mariano Rivera
P John Smoltz
P Livan Hernandez
P Joe Kennedy
P Bartolo Colon
P Freddy Garcia
P Odalis Perez
P Joel Pineiro
P Sidney Ponson
Bench Chris Carpenter
Bench Woody Williams
IR Al Leiter
C Craig A. Wilson
1B Adam Dunn
2B Orlando Hudson
3B Eric Chavez
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Carlos Beltran
OF Vladimir Guerrero
OF Scott Podsednik
OF Brian Giles
OF Carlos Lee
2B/SS Jose Valentin
1B/3B Rafael Palmeiro
Util Joe Crede
Bench Kazuo Matsui
Or
Team B: P Brandon Webb,
P Eric Gagne,
P Trevor Hoffman
P Nate Field,
P LaTroy Hawkins,
P Brian Lawrence,
P Ben Sheets,
P Tim Worrell,
P Nathan Robertson,
Bench Billy Wagner* , Phi
C Jason Varitek,
1B Paul Konerko,
2B Jerry Hairston, Jr.,
3B Vinny Castilla,
SS Edgar Renteria,
OF Alex Sanchez,
OF Albert Pujols,
OF Corey Patterson,
OF Torii Hunter,
OF Vernon Wells,
2B/SS Angel Berroa,
1B/3B Morgan Ensberg,
Util Mark Teixeira,
Bench Jim Thome*
Bench Adrian Beltre,
IR David Roberts* , LA [/b]
I'd say Team 2 has the better offense by a pretty good margin. However he has no pitching whatsoever, while Team 1 has good starters and 2 great closers. I'd say Team 1 has the better overall team definately since there is no pitching for Team 2.