Blockbuster involving rivera/hallday...ill help u if u help

[twiens]

AL only Keeper League
Head to Head 5x5 scoring

I get Rivera/Gordon
He gets Halladay/Guardado

Im thinking of jus giving up halladays wins and K's and going for the saves,whip and era instead.........
is this a good trade for me?

Heres my roster at this time(we all started with the roster of an AL team..thats why there almost all mariners)

C) Dan Wilson
1b)Jon Olerud
2b)Orlando Hudson
3b)Scott Spiezio
SS)R.Aurillia
LF)R.Ibanez
CF)R.Winn
RF)I.Suzuki
Util)J.Gonzalez
Bench-E.Martinez
Bench-P.Borders
Bench-Q.McCracken

SP)R.Halladay
SP)J.Moyer
RP)E.Guardado
RP)S.Hasegawa
P)F.Garcia
P)R.Franklin
P)R.Villone
Bench)J.Mateo
DL)R.Soriano

Im currently in 5th place

[jlamorgese]

Whatever you do, don't pull the trigger on this trade. It has everything wrong with it for you, especially in a Keeper League. You are trading youth for age, you are selling low and buying high, and while there are two of the better closers in the AL involved, you are trading an elite starter for a setup man. Halladay is a guy that you can build your staff around for years to come, and likely will wind up wearing pinstripes before his career is over. At any rate, there is no way that you should do this trade.

--JL

[ajgnydc722]

I agree with the above post. No way pull the trigger. Halladay is too good and you're also losing Guardado. Stick with what you have.

Help me out please: http://fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/v ... hp?t=63438

[sanjit4]

i wouldnt do that trade either.
My Teamhttp://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=63502

[wildcat25]

ENOUGH SAID DONT EVEN THINK ABOUT IT!

[mwb743s]

Dont do it

[satchel paige]

don't make this trade. SP for RP doesn't give you enough help when you consider IP value of RP.

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... 360#419360[/url]