Pat Burrell or Vinny Castilla?

[WhiteHot]

Castilla is old. For some reason, I don't like old players on my team.

[ajgnydc722]

I also like Burrell.

[warrick95]

I like Burrell, but Vinny is looking awfully good since he's playing half his games at Coors...30 homers and 100 RBIs are not out of reach if he stays in the cleanup spot. But since he shouldn't, we should pull our estimates down to 90 RBIs.

[NZF]

I like Burrell, but Vinny is looking awfully good since he's playing half his games at Coors...30 homers and 100 RBIs are not out of reach if he stays in the cleanup spot. But since he shouldn't, we should pull our estimates down to 90 RBIs.

100 RBI's are a given even if Wilson and Larry came back tomorrow. He has 40 odd already after just 1/4 of the season completed. He should go close to 120 even if he gets demoted to 6 after the break.

[athxu]

Burrell if you need an everyday outfield. But I can see cases when you want to platoon Castilla during his home games. In a shallow league Castilla would be more valuable. I mean, look at his stats at home. They're GAUDY.

[Members Only Jackets]

Castilla

[Pedro]

Vinny.

Never underestimate the Coors Field Factor, especially with Vinny.