I was in almost the exact same situation as you, only I have Hudson and Durham was on my league's FA list. I just picked up Durham, b/c he's much more proven. Plus I think he'll end up with more steals, which is what I'm really looking for. He also will have a better average. Obviously, his durability is a concern, but I think you will be able to find players similar to Hudson on your league's FA list if he decides to get injured again.