Garciaparra will not even come close to the numbers of cabrera...Cabrera is a stud and will keep on trucking
Even if the above were true, which I doubt, Nomar plays SS. I'd still much rather have Nomar. And while Cabrera also has 3B eligibility, 3B is INSANELY deep this year, who would have thought?
(Edit): Oh, and I forgot to mention, as deep as 3B is right now, SS is even more remarkably shallow. I should know, I'm the one fighting for a spot in the wading pool (Everett, Cintron, Uribe, etc. etc. etc.