O. Cabrera or Furcal?

[bm4844]

I have a hole at SS for a little while longer. Both are available, who would you pick up?

Should I drop V. Zambrano, Dye, or Reyes? I don't think he'll be back for quite a while.

Yahoo Roto League (R, HR, RBI, SB, AVG, OPS; W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, K/BB)

C-Posada
1B-Texiera
2B-Boone
SS-Nomar (DL)
3B-Aramis Ramirez
OF-Vladdy
OF-Dye
OF-Chipper
Util-Rondell White
BN-Preston Wilson (DL)
DL-Reyes

SPs
-Millwood
-Padilla
-V. Zambrano
-C. Zambrano
-Peavy
-Colon
-Clement
-Prior (DL)

RPs
-Percival
-Herges
-Graves

[hooligan1]

I don't think I'd drop Dye yet. I still think he will be very solid all season long. Victor is definately your weakest SP and I have dropped or traded Reyes in four different leagues; it doesn't look as though he'll be back for a while and even when he doed get back, is he really going to be playing the way you need him to be? I doubt it.....

I'm a bit suprised that either Cabrera or Furcal are even available; short-sightedness on someone's part......

I would personally drop either Reyes or V Zambrano and pick up Furcal over Cabrera.....although neither is a particularly poor choice!

[matmat]

cabrera for v zambrano.

[jbones733]

depends what you need, Cabrera has some more pop & will get you more ribbies, Furcal will score more runs & steal more bases, so make your decision upon that,

considering both are avaiable I would drop Reyes, both of those guys are btter than him even when healthy