jose guillen or jermaine dye

[John Bonzo]

Guillen, while I don't think he'll post 30+ HR's like last year, I don't expect Dye to either. Dye will most likely hit about .260 as well and drag your teams average down.

I agree about Dye, though Guillen only hit 23 last year and i can see him matching that again this year.

Guillen did hit 31 last year. 23 in Cinci and 8 in Oakland, and I'd take him over Dye.

You're right...my mistake. I would take him over Dye as well.

[john gardner]

I like Dye because he has a longer and, therefore more predictable, record of success.

[shortround_phat2008]

Another vote for Guillen!

[Teddy K.G.B.]

Guillen...

Dye had a horrible season last year so I don't think the "longer track record of success" argument holds as much water. Guillen is in a better lineup as mentioned before. Dye hit 7 bombs in his first 13 games and 0 in his last 15.

[ajgnydc722]

Dye will have a big rebound year this season. I'd take him over Guillen.

[shortround_phat2008]

Dye will have a rebound year this year, and the only reason why he had a horrible season last year was injuries, but I would still go with Guillen.

[Eaglez]

Dye...

I expect .270 25hrs 100 rbi and 85+ runs

[Ender]

Dye has had 2 good years and one mediocre years followed by multiple years plagued with injuries, hardly a safer track record. Guillen was supposed to be a stud for a few years and never panned out then finally had his big year at the age of 28. Yes, I think he got a few extra HR's because of where he played but the fact that he hasnt' had the injury concerns and he's in a very powerful lineup would make me give him the edge. Also guillen is hot right now and dye has cooled way off so if you want bang for your buck right now, he's the better choice.