do i need to do this trade ?

[tristan_799]

hers the trade Anderson, Garret (LF-Ana) and Salmon, Tim (RF, DH-Ana) for my Furcal, Rafael (SS-Atl) and Morris, Matt (SP-StL)

heres both our team i am the ottawa o's



ottawa o's
C Kendall, Jason (C-Pit)
1B Durazo, Erubiel (1B-Oak)
2B Alomar, Roberto (2B-NYM)
3B Rolen, Scott (3B-StL)
SS Rollins, Jimmy (SS-Phi)
CF Griffey Jr., Ken (CF-Cin)
RF Sheffield, Gary (RF-Atl)
OF Erstad, Darin (CF-Ana)
IF Dunn, Adam (LF, 1B, RF-Cin)
Util Burks, Ellis (DH-Cle)

bench
Furcal, Rafael (SS-Atl)
Finley, Steve (CF-Ari)
Hidalgo, Richard(RF-Hou)
Jordan, Brian (LF-LA)
Huff, Aubrey (DH, 1B-TB)
Martinez, Edgar (DH-Sea)
Lofton, Kenny (CF-Pit)


pitchers
Mussina, Mike (SP-NYY)
Oswalt, Roy (SP-Hou)
Morris, Matt (SP-StL)
Stewart, Scott (RP-Mon)
Mantei, Matt (RP-Ari)
Brown, Kevin (SP, RP-LA)
Prior, Mark (SP-ChC)
Armas Jr., Tony (SP-Mon)
Kim, Byung-Hyun (RP-Ari)

Calgary Renegades
C Posada, Jorge (C-NYY)
1B Palmeiro, Rafael (1B, DH-Tex)
2B Durham, Ray (2B, DH-SF)
3B Randa, Joe (3B, DH-KC)
SS Jeter, Derek (SS-NYY)
LF Matsui, Hideki (LF-NYY)
CF Abreu, Bobby (RF, CF-Phi)
RF Suzuki, Ichiro (RF-Sea)
OF Anderson, Garret (LF-Ana)
IF Boone, Aaron (3B, SS-Cin)
Util Salmon, Tim (RF, DH-Ana)

Bench Winn, Randy (CF-Sea)
Bench Fullmer, Brad (DH, 1B-Ana)
Bench Tucker, Michael (RF, LF, DH-KC)
Bench Hernandez, Jose (SS-Col)
Bench Polanco, Placido (3B-Phi)


pitchers
Johnson, Randy (SP-Ari)
Buehrle, Mark (SP-CWS)
Pineiro, Joel (SP, RP-Sea)
Dotel, Octavio (RP-Hou)
Daal, Omar (SP, RP-Bal)
Reed, Rick (SP-Min)
Appier, Kevin (SP-Ana)

Bench Lidle, Cory (SP-Tor)
Bench Contreras, Jose (SP-NYY)
Bench Dempster, Ryan (SP-Cin)
Bench Julio, Jorge (RP-Bal)

[tristan_799]

my bad wrong forum

[Payne Dailey]

don't do it Morris is hard to replace

If this particular answer was helpful to you, click here. (You can click on none or multiple replies in your thread.)

[tristan_799]

yea but the only reason i am thinking of it is because i have a few other decent ones.... would this help my team??

[drunkenmonkey]

Salmon doesn't do much for you and Garrett Anderson is a good outfielder, but you are giving up a top pitcher and a SS that just might be better than the one you are starting (depending on your scoring method). This guy seems to be loaded at outfielder. See if you can upgrade from Anderson or downgrade your pitcher offered.

If this particular answer was helpful to you, click here. (You can click on none or multiple replies in your thread.)

[hooligan1]

Dude, no way I would do this trade. On the surface it is actually fair, but Morris is really hard to replace even though you have Mussina and Oswalt and Prior. Anderson and Salmon are not much better (if at all) than what you already have in the OF, although you do have the Griffey risk....I'm probably the only one who feels this way about Morris, but unless I'm getting a top ten bat in return, why would I trade away a top ten pitcher.....because that's what Morris is. Anderson might, MIGHT, be a top fifteen OF and Salmon is a ways farther down the list. Even getting rid of Furcal doesn't even this trade in your favor.......Don't do it!!!

If this particular answer was helpful to you, click here. (You can click on none or multiple replies in your thread.)

[hooligan1]

I don't want to sound like I'm totally down on Furcal, but he has been having injury problems. I do agree with Drunkenmonkey, though that Furcal could be better than your current starter, Rollins. I still stand by my statement that I would not do this trade......

If this particular answer was helpful to you, click here. (You can click on none or multiple replies in your thread.)

[tristan_799]

thanks i got rid of the trade but what should i expect for matt morris in return ? like whats his worth?