Who's better (5x5): Zambrano, Penny, Webb

[shortround_phat2008]

Emotional problems, give me a break you have to be kidding, Zammy and Penny are both way better than Webb in my opinion, Zammy is prolly the best out of the three though.

[jbones733]

Not allowed to vote anymore but if we were i would go

Zambrano
Penny
Webb


all 3 are awesome younsta's

[Silver Slugger]

I take the big Z any day. I had both him and Webb on my team last year (I had one really good month with the waiver wire :-) ). However, I still have to go with Z for the crazy low WHIP and the totally underrated strikeout total. Webb is also phenominal. I actually think Penny is probably the weakest out of the three.

Oh, yeah, and Z will turn 23 next month, so he's crazy young and will probably get better. So in any league, any format, keeper or non-keeper (although especially keeper) you gotta go with zambrano.

[pibb55]

Well his emotions killed him last year so they do matter, I live in the Chicago area and get all the games on TV, last year after a call he didnt agree with or a home run hed pitch differently and that would be the end of the game for him pretty much. He is maturing though and those problems may be a thing of the past, maybe not though... its only be a month and a half or so.

[CubsFan7724]

Ya his emotions sure killed him in his first full year starting..... 13 wins, 168 ks in 214 innings, 3.11 ERA, 1.32 WHIP, 11 Losses, 3 CGs, 1 SO, 9 HRs given up, 74 ER, if only my 21 year old pitcher werent so emotional he would not have had such a bad season Those numbers are damn good to me.