Dunn or Dye: Whos more valuable??

[Fender1114]

I'm getting a lot of interest in both of these guys with their hot starts, and i wanna trade ONE of them to help solidify my IF. I have a tom of OFs (Manny, Ichiro, Edmonds, Dye, Dunn, Sanchez, Guillen, Stewart) and Sweeney at first. who am i better of trading?? DUnn or Dye?? they r both hot now, but who will stay that way??

[awwchrist]

Trade whichever one brings you the most value on your infield return. I like Dye's potential myself.

[hybrid]

well since you have a lot of OF's, Dunn might be more valuable to you as he can also play 1B. Other then that I like both to have pretty good years. So if you really want to trade one and it doesn't matter that Dunn can play 1st, you might as well trade the one you get a better deal for. Though personally I like Dunn more cause he has more power, can play 1st, and will steal you some bases.

[ajgnydc722]

dye

[Cornbread Maxwell]

who should you trade?

Dunn - no doubt about it. Check out his splits - April has always been his best month. He peaks very early and then falls off the table after May.

Maybe this is the yr - or maybe he is the ideal early season sell high candidate that he has been the last 2 yrs.

[Base Ballpickers]

dunn is younger, powerful, and developing into a patient hitter. In the last 9 years, Dye has only reached 400 or more at bats 3 times. His average has declined every year since 2000 which is the only year he EVER hit .300 or higher. I would take dye if I could get him, but if I had to choose between dunn or dye...well, you already know that. I don't think dye's past allows me to believe that he will be around the whole year.

[point06]

Dye, gonna have one helluva comeback year on a team that will dominate. He is their new star and will carry them as far as he can.

[Bloody Nipples]

Dye is better than Dunn, but he is underrated because of supposed injury problems. Therefore, you could get more in return for Dunn, while keeping the better player. Keep Dye; trade Dunn.

[Melo255]

Keep Dye