Rate these 3 pitchers.............

[Carnac]

Jose Contreras NYY
Jerome Williams SF
Ryan Franklin SEA

Have Contreras and Williams but am considering picking up Franklin on FA list for one of them. Am I wrong?

[Zito is God]

Contreras
Franklin
Williams

[BobbyRoberto]

I'd stay away from Franklin. The Mariners lost a lot of defense from last year and Franklin doesn't strike anyone out, so he needs a good outfield. Randy Winn has looked bad in center, especially compared to how good Mike Cameron was last year. Rich Aurilia isn't a good glove at short. Scott Spiezio has little experience at 3B. Franklin relies on his defense a lot, so he's risky with the downgrades the M's have from last year.