TRADE HOFFMAN??

[TIGERTOWN]

I'm in a 12 team roto league and was offered Pudge and Jeter for Billy Wagner. I'm not giving up Wagner, but I also have Hoffman. Should I trade Hoffman for Pudge and Jeter. Currently have Berroa and Ramon Hernandez at short and catcher. THANK YOU FOR YOUR INPUT!!!

[paulman8]

It depends on who's available on the WW in your league. If there are other closers available, or you have one on your bench, do it. If not, then wait until you get a deal involving another closer...but berroa's hurt now (migraines, 15 day DL), so you kinda need to take action fast.

[reenum]

I would do it, since Jeter will be back to his high average batting in that lineup, and Pudge is in a decent lineup in Detroit.

Hoffman, on the other hand is an injury risk, given his age and history.

[rewrw]

hoffman is not even at the same level as wagner..theres no way theotherg uy willaccept.