Which hitter Edgar or Milton

[Big Blue]

from a hitters standpoint which one will put up better #'s position does not matter

[TD]

I'd like to know the same thing! They're both on my bench and am thinkin' about dropping one of them for Bo. Crosby.

Any thoughts?

[kentx12]

I would go with Edgar. He is an injury risk but if healthy he will give you solid numbers.

[Spartans Rule]

Milton, easily. He's young and durable and fast and improving.

Edgar is old and brittle and slow and declining.

[bestinwest]

Edgar all the way, hes underrated, definitely him, .300-20-100 type hitter, people think hes too old to put up numbers but look what hes doin hes awesome

[Leiter Fan]

I assume by "Edgar" you mean Martinez, and not Renteria??

And by "Milton", you mean Bradley, and not Eric Milton, the pitcher??

Boy, you think it would kill some people to actually type out both a first and last name.

[Big Blue]

yes Milton Bradley and Edgar Martinez thank you pointing that out

[bestinwest]

I assume by "Edgar" you mean Martinez, and not Renteria??

And by "Milton", you mean Bradley, and not Eric Milton, the pitcher??

Boy, you think it would kill some people to actually type out both a first and last name.

It's kind of obvious he meant Edgar Martinez and Milton bradley, If it were Renteria he wouldn't be asking that question, it's just common sense...

[bestinwest]

I assume by "Edgar" you mean Martinez, and not Renteria??

And by "Milton", you mean Bradley, and not Eric Milton, the pitcher??

Boy, you think it would kill some people to actually type out both a first and last name.

It's kind of obvious he meant Edgar Martinez and Milton bradley, If it were Renteria he wouldn't be asking that question, it's just common sense...

[Pogotheostrich]

[quote="Spartans Rule"]Milton, easily. He's young and durable and fast and improving.
[quote] Durable? Not really but I would take him over Edgar.