Ya'll probably saw the post today about Mark Prior. I've been considering a few trades during the past week due to his injury. With the latest news, I'm in a quandry; how unethical is it right now to try and deal him?
Asymmetric knowledge is one of the characteristics of fantasy baseball. The people who know things will generally do better than those you don't. If you're going to engage in a transaction, it's your responsibility to know what is involved in the transaction, not someone else's. If you can take advantage of someone limited knowledge, it's your prerogative to do so. That's fantasy baseball.
Personally I hate the yellow notes Yahoo puts by players. It levels the playing field between those who do research and those who don't.
I do think it is unethical to trade a player you know to be injured when the other player is unaware of this. You are moving 'damaged goods' in that case. But with Yahoo's designating players with a 'DL', this is now rarely the case.
In this case, people are aware that Prior is currently on the DL. If you offer him in a trade, I think it is fair of you to assume that the person you are offering him to is aware that he is on the DL and injured. It is then incumbent upon them to determine the severity of the injury and to decide if they want to take the risk of trading for him.
You don't need to tell him every rumor that you've heard about Prior's injury. Why would you when the rumors are unsubstantiated? As it stands, the Cubs are keeping things rather hush-hush. In fact, you don't need to tell him anything more than that Prior is currently on the DL.
If you want to trade Prior, make an offer. If you want to be ethical, don't lie if you are asked any questions. If you are asked about Prior's injury, it is fair to simply say that you don't know how serious it is and that you aren't sure when he is expected back. Really, that's all that anybody knows at this point.
"The game has a cleanness. If you do a good job, the numbers say so. You don't have to ask anyone or play politics. You don't have to wait for the reviews." - Sandy Koufax
I've been contemplating trading prior, too. Last week i rejected an offer that would have sent Prior and O. Cabrera away for K. Brown and J. Guillen. While i didn't like that specific deal (the guy put guillen on waivers the day i regected the offer) I thought the prior for brown (along with some other mid value players) was at least intriguing. Am I jumping the gun here, or do you think i should jump on this, hope KB stays healthy, and never look back?
98% of Americans have a favorable opinion of puppies and rainbows.
How do you spell "biased?"
Minor League Mentor
Joined: 15 Jan 2003
Bases this season: 0
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Living Room, Watchin Baseball on Mute, Ignoring Idiot Red Sox and Yankee Fans