Prior or Schilling?

[Manutd016]

What are your reasons for your preference?

[mtarail]

1) Schilling is healthy and will give you a hell of a lot more innings than Prior

2) He'll should win at least 3 more games and looks like a lock for 20+

3) He'll strike out MANY more guys than Prior

4) The only possible advantage that Prior offers is a superior ERA, but returning from an injury even that isn't a lock.

Based on past stats and his current health, Schilling looks like the best pitcher in the AL right now (unless Pedro gets his velocity back.)

[whitesox04champs]

I love prior but his injury is just BAD.....

no question its SCHILLING

[CubsFan7724]

before the injury i woulda said prior, but now id want schilling.

[inkubus]

Anybody hear Schilling in the Jungle today?

[frog99]

Schilling, the man is horse.


Plus he isn't hurt.

[thetongueofire]

obviously Schilling cos of Prior's injury

[bucsfan04]

If not for the injury, then Prior is the obvious choice. But now i think Schilling is better.

[blankman]

again, Schilling