fsbarren wrote:I like Votto. You know what you're getting and he's pretty reliable for his numbers.
Either way, both are top 5 1Bs.
With Votto… last 3 years he has 29, 14, and 24 HR… with 103, 56, and 73 RBI. One of those years was an injury year… last year his RBI number was way down. With Fielder… last three years his HR numbers have been slipping 38, 30, 25… but his RBI numbers were solid and over 100 each time and he's played 162 games in each of those 3 years.
I feel that you know what you're getting with Fielder, more so than with Votto.