Prior / Alfonseca for Washburn / Williamson

[jmc_47]

Looking to upgrade my closers, I tried to get Williamson in a package for Alfonseca in a package. The owner countered with Jarrod Washburn and Scott Williamson for Mark Prior and Antonio Alfonseca. In a 5x5, should I go for it?

[Spike]

No, no, no!

[Pogotheostrich]

No, Washburn isn't going to put up last year's numbers and even though I like Williamson more than Alfonseca, he isn't good enough or a proven enough closer to make up the difference between Prior and Washburn.

[wrveres]

hit that delete button and pass on that trade. hell no. I wouldn't pull that deal.

[guest]

don't even think about it. Prior could be top 10 starter this season and if your league counts strikeouts, he's even more valuable.