I would make that trade if I were you. The reason is this: I'd prefer Cutch over Stanton and A. Jones. JOnes' OBP is not very good (he never walks!), so in an OBP league, his value takes a minor hit. You should definitely improve your team for this season (stanton has struggled all year), and probably be neutral to better for next year.
With your current team, I'd keep:
Pedroia (or maybe Machado--not sure)
With the trade, you'd keep:
I always value position players more than SPs since they're a lot easier to plug in. OF is also the easiest position to fill in-season or via draft (there are a lot more of them than any other position obviously), so giving up two OFs in the top 15 to get a top 5 player to me is a good move.
Help me please. viewtopic.php?t=463791