12 team, head to head, 6x6 category, keeper league.
Trade option 1:
Give- JP Arencibia, Andre Ethier
Receive- Alex Rios
Trade Option 2:
Give- JP Arencibia, Andre Ethier, Heath Bell
Receive- BJ Upton, Kris Medlen, Travis Wood
I have 3 catchers, Arencibia is the worst of them. The league has 4 OF positions and Ethier is my worse starting OF (if you think Nate McLouth is better). Also, my pitching isn't too great, but I don't have much in the way of closers. Which trade would you do?