I mean, your team is stacked regardless. You;ve got more than enough SP even if you lost Price, and CC is no slouch. The upgrade from AGonz to Pujols is not huge but not insignificant either. At the end of the deal, you have a stronger offense, and your pitching has not suffered a great deal.
And why not move one of those other stud 1B for a top-15 SP and make your rotation just as strong as your bats?
Is AGon eligable at OF in your league? If so then I might stay put as you have a lot at 1B already. If not then I could see the deal but as mentioned above, doesn't really do a whole lot for you. I think Price finishes a fair bit better than CC this year.
He is not an eligible outfielder. My thinking is that the difference between Pujols and agonz is greater than the difference between price and cc. Plus hitting is valued higher than pitching. Any thoughts?