Why would you sit either of them?
Those are two middle-top tier pitchers. You shouldn't be benching them ever.
Mauer, A-Gonz, Pedroia, Miggy, E. Cabrera, Beltran, Morse, Holliday, Beltre, Gomez, Rizzo, puig, Hanley
Greinke, Johnson, Haren, wheeler, pineda, E santana, Ryu, Miller, Garza, Street, Frieri, Gregg, Putz, gregerson
10 man H2H Yahoo 5x5