Would you trade Eric Hosmer 5.00 for Manny Machado also 5.00 in a 12 team AL only league? Standard 5x5 scoring. The big difference between the two is Hosmer can't be kept after this year. Machado can be kept next year and his contract could be extended next year at 5.00 per year.
Third base is very weak this year with Youkilis , Donaldson, Dominquez and Caroll the best avalible.
First base is much deeper with Albert, Fielder, Trumbo, Tex, Morneau, Morales, Swisher Konerko , Dunn and Youk avalible.
I have not made the offer yet . Just wanted the opinions of the forum first.