It's a long post, so I apologize. Long story short, I have a few offers on the table right now. We keep 8 players, and I currently have both Miggy and Longoria. Felix and Wainwright are my top 2 SP's. I have a few trades brewing, one involves Tulo and McCutchen. My question is, out of these 4 possible scenarios, which would you make your team out to be?
(We keep 8, so Round 1 is really Round 9) (10th means 10th overall pick, so round 9, pick 10) THIS IS MY TEAM CURRENTLY 1B Votto 2B Kinsler 3B Miggy SS OF Justin Upton OF OF UTIL Longoria
10th, 11th, 21st, 30th, 31st
(Trading Longoria for Ian Desmond and Desmond Jennings) 1B Votto 2B Kinsler 3B Miggy SS Desmond OF Justin Upton OF Desmond Jennings OF
10th, 11th, 18th, 21st, 31st
(Trading Miggy and 2 picks for Tulo and McCutchen) 1B Votto 2B Kinsler 3B Longoria SS Tulo OF Justin Upton OF McCutchen OF
11th overall, 21st overall, 31 overall
(Doing both trades above, selecting Lawrie 1st overall) 1B Votto 2B Kinsler 3B Lawrie SS Tulo OF Justin Upton OF McCutchen OF Jennings
If I had to choose one, I'd say the Longoria trade only. This is such a shallow league that amassing picks isn't going to be overly beneficial because there will be decent replacement players at the end of the draft/on waivers. I really dno't care for any deal in which you give up Miggy.
As mentioned by another poster, I think Jennings/Desmond is probably getting overrated. Not a big fan of any of the scenarios really.