Our draft is coming up this week and I ended up trading my way up the draft.... I have first overall via trade and my own original pick (8th). I had great squad but failed in first round playoff. See the draft's key players as follows. Hanley's injury has me playing ideas.... I originally thought CC to really build my pitching, and then looking at deeper for perhaps Freese or Rutledge for left side of infield later. Headley sitting there has me thinking. I need these first two picks to count as I don't pick again until third round, though I have four picks in that round. CC was my last player cut... That's why not protected... Others were let go even in deeper league.
Options to draft: Pick your top five options in order...
51Sabathia, CC 61Headley, Chase 79 Choo, Shin-Soo 91 Konerko, Paul 93Papelbon, Jonathan 100Motte, Jason 101Victorino, Shane 105Freese, David 107Weeks, Rickie 108Rosario, Wilin 109Samardzija, Jeff 115Peavy, Jake 118Ortiz, David 122Davis, Chris 124Rivera, Mariano 126Rodney, Fernando 130Nathan, Joe 132Aoki, Norichika 134Markakis, Nick 135Harvey, Matt
My roster info below: 14 Team League. Head to Head. Beyond 10th Year Now. Built Well. 11 Keepers. Contracts are 3 years only. With Buddies Since Tee Ball. Competitive. Contracts Renew When Traded. Expire Yr in ( ) Compete in following 6x6 areas: OBP H HR RBI R SB WHIP IP ERA SO W SV
MY ROSTER C 1B Albert Pujols (2014) 2B 3B David Wright (2015) SS Hanley Ramirez (2015) OF Mike Trout (2014) OF Jose Bautista (OF) (2014) OF Justin Upton (2014) Util Matt Kemp (2015) Util Bench
Pitching Staff (Play 9/week) SP Zach Greinke (2015) SP Cliff Lee (2013) SP Madison Bumgarner (2014) SP SP RP Craig Kimbrel (2013) RP P P Bull Pen:
Expos... Gone, but not forgotten.
Hall of Fame Hero
(Past Year: 192)
Joined: 6 Apr 2005
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Enjoying America's Pastime with a Canadian Beer!
Considering none of the other players can make near the impact it has to be CC. Although I think he'll have somewhat of a drop-off this year he is still the best player on the board and will help your pitching staff.
I would go with CC and then a closer due to the 14 team issue. Given it's a keeper it might be more interesting to take Headley over CC, if only because your pitching is solid as it is and Headley for the next couple of years (possibly on another MLB team) would be a good skill player to have in the Util spot. Up to you.
Snake draft, you have to go best available (sometimes even if it doesn't fit a true need).
If i'm you I'm going CC with the first pick (don't forget that Headley is also hurt, and has really only performed well one year), and then Willin Rosario (and if he's gone, Samardzija) with the 8th pick. You can always use CC as trade bait to get a 2B/SS if needed.
Yeah talk about Slim Pickens riding the a-bomb going woo-hoo in his cowboy hat... I suppose I too would go with CC as the #1 pick in an attempt to make your pitching a noticeable strength as opposed to overdrafting someone in order to plug a hole. Given the names listed there I wouldn't overpay to have any of them at 2B/C, but then again I'm not the biggest Willn Rosario guy.... if Miguel Montero and his perennial ~.280/18/80 type offense is there he's a nice floor to have in terms of catching production; I have him in a bunch of leagues this year as I didn't want to roll the dice and risk a floor to have a ceiling, figuring .275/15/75 in a blah-ish year is solid enough to have at catcher.
another thing is that I like Matt Harvey over Jeff Samardzija. SHARK Samardzija is getting his propers for being the opening day starter, but he's coming off of a "breakout" year where he was 3.81/1.30 or something? That high WHIP worries me cuz a lot of times pitchers who have a ~1.30/ish WHIP they're obviously letting people on base a bunch and it usually breaks towards them having a higher ERA the next season unless they can get that WHIP down to ~1.20-1.25. Sure Harvey is a candidate to have his 2.73/1.15 regress somewhat, but those ~70k in ~58 innings or whatever are really nice. I think he has a higher upside than Samardzija over the next 3 years, just don't go into this assuming he's going to duplicate the 2.73/1.15 or even improve on it.... sure it's possible, but if he had a full season of ~3.45/1.23 or something you'd take it and run with it. it'll be interesting to see what an offseason of tape study and his 2nd go-around will do for him.
In terms of 2B, man, i bet you can land someone like the aforementioned Rutledge later on, or an Everth Cabrera if you wanna mortgage any inklings of power in order to get those SB, or hell maybe you can bet that this is the year that Gordon Beckham reclaims his early success and hits .280/+ cuz if he were to do that, I reckon he'd get his ~18/+ HRs and ~75/+ RBIs.
Also, I'd be leery of getting Fernando Rodney with a 3-year window in mind. Tampa has Jake McGee doing his thing and looking absolutely dominant and no matter what Rodney does, short of replicating last year for the remainder of his contract and accepting less than $5mil/yr because he wants to stay in Tampa Bay, Jake McGee will be closing in that timeframe. Shoot, if you've got your roster pretty much stacked and you've got enough SP/closers and you wanna get someone who could be an !! closer for ~2/3 of the upcoming years I'd heartily recommend Jake McGee as your guy over the Vinnie Pestanos of the world. In standard 5x5 scoring without counting holds McGee was ranked #137 overall last year.
So yeah, I reckon with pick #1 i'd go CC and then at pick #9 i'd hope Matt Harvey is there (and figure he prolly will be) but then I'd be treating #1 as a pick to help in the immediate future and using my #9 pick as a futures pick. Shoot, you could even invest that #9 in a profar/taveras/myers/eaton type prospect in the hopes of them developing into a future-for-sure-keeper over the next 2-3 years.
MashinSpuds wrote:Damn impressive candid commentary there. Next time I start a thread in this forum I'm PM'ing sinicalypse.
Samardzija's WHIP was 1.22 last year, so it kinda blows the argument out of the water. Plus I think alot of his hype is based on the fact that he got stronger in the second half which was impressive for a guy that was setting career highs in IP. He trended in the right direction last year.
I like Harvey and he has alot of potential but Samardzija has proven it a little more at this point.
That being said I think I take CC with the first pick and then probably Roasrio at 8th based on the Roster makeup. However I am extremely high on Choo this year, and might like him with the 8th pick as well.
1. Sin Shoo Choo - A no brainer for me. Even if you did not have the pitching that you do, Choo is an absolutely ridiculous sleeper this year. I currently have him ranked as my 41st pick overall. He strikes out a bit much but I am looking at him as lock on 100/20/70/20/.290!!!!!!!!!! with upside of 115/25/80/25/.300 and an absolute bottom of 100/15/70/20/.275 that I feel will in no way happen. This guy strikes out a bit much so I do not consider him to be a first tier OF, but he could really show off this year in Cinci and has been a model of consistency (aside for his one year hurt).
2. CC - Interesting pick but safe enough I guess. I am concerned that he is on the decline and his numbers will inflate a bit. Regardless he should be good for 15-16/3.45/1.2/180-200. I would look into maybe drafting him first only if you feel that the next round you draft in will have no pitchers at all.
3. Pap - Would be nice to have 2 dominant closers. Most people abide by the rule of waiting on closer; all this does is make it more difficult to snag one off of the waiver wire when everyone is searching for those saves.
4. Konerko - I love this old bugger. He is a lock for 25 ding dongs and close to .300 avg, not bad for a late round utility pick.
5. Headley - Hurt but might be interesting if looking to use as keeper. Would hurt you this season.
6. Jeff Samadajayajdha - Don't draft this guy with these 2 picks. Let someone else pick the CHICAGO CUB lol.