Would You Veto This?

[RedHopeful]

Jose Reyes/Oscar Taveras/Shelby Miller

for

Josh Reddick/Chris Sale/2nd round pick

20 team yahoo dynasty where 22 of a roster of 25 are kept each season. Std categories + OPS + Holds

[msing]

Seems like a fair trade from here.

Established player + Potential + Potential
Established player + Medium + 2nd Round ...

With keeping 20 of the 23, I suppose the 2nd Round doesn't have that much talent.

[converge241]

Id rather have the reyes/taveras side, but not vetoable. I can certainly understand a reaction/feeling of asking.

I don't believe in Reddick or hold much value in him, but there are fans and I could be wrong.

[Ender]

Veto's are a pretty hard area to talk about.

It is a pretty terrible deal imo and I say that as someone who doesn't like Reyes much. That doesn't mean it should be vetoed out of hand though, it just depends on how your league views things. I can see where the deal makes sense in a redraft league, in a dynasty league it feels pretty bad.

[Havok1517]

I like the Reyes side better depending on what the 2nd rounder might amount to.

[bigken117]

I'd take the Reyes side

[j24jags]

I definitely prefer the Reyes side, but I'm generally against vetoing unless collusion is evident. That certainly depends on the precedents set in the past in your league. While the upside of Miller and Taveras is enticing, neither has done anything at the major league level yet so it is difficult to weigh their value in the trade.

[jfg]

I don't think it's veto worthy. Like others said, vetos should only be used when it's obvious the owners are colluding.

[thedude]

I don't think it's veto worthy. Like others said, vetos should only be used when it's obvious the owners are colluding.

This.

I would love to get the Reyes side, but I would never veto that. To play the devil's advocate, I understand why someone would want Chris Sale, he is young and has the potential to be a dominant starter for years.

[MashinSpuds]

Can't say I'd veto either, as it depends on what a manager sees in certain players. Perhaps the manager getting Reddick thinks he's 20+ HR talent for years to come, and hopes that Chris Sale is a steady contributor that gets stats now and is not a wait-and-see kind of guy (Miller). I don't know what the 2nd pick could get the manager, but if it's a solid enough prospect/player then maybe it's worth it.

The name values flash brightly for the Reyes side, and in a dynasty I personally would prefer to roll with Taveras and Miller for years to come, but I think one manager in that deal has a different opinion. I'd say let it go through.