Trade offer involving Profar

[TurdFerguson]

Ive been offered Matt Moore for Profar... Its a H2H league.. Im really torn on the deal because Moore seems to have control issues and its simply hard to deal someone of Profars caliber.. I do have Starlin at SS but I think Profar gets moved to 2B.. My staff is hurting though is what really makes me want to do it.. Its a Dynasty with minor drafts every year.. Any help would be appreciated

[RedHopeful]

Even though I'm a fan of Moore, I think you have to keep Profar. Of course, I'm assuming standard categories here.

[jeffmerk]

If two players seem relatively close in value, always take the hitter over the pitcher.

[TurdFerguson]

Thanks for the response.. Ive been offered Rizzo for Profar.. Im a huge Rizzo fan and have Tex with no other prospect for the future.. He saw the Tex injury and assumed I would bite.. Would anyone consider Rizzo?

[RedHopeful]

Thanks for the response.. Ive been offered Rizzo for Profar.. Im a huge Rizzo fan and have Tex with no other prospect for the future.. He saw the Tex injury and assumed I would bite.. Would anyone consider Rizzo?

Stick with Profar.

[PlayingWithFire]

I'm not even bullish on Profar. But you gotta get more.

[TurdFerguson]

Thanks for the responses.. I feel pretty much like the rest of you.. Im not going to deal him unless someone overwhelms me with an offer..

[BigLebowski]

You gotta take your team into account. Can you win this year? If not then hold Profar. If yes then consider a trade. You do need to get more than Rizzo, but I like Rizzo and expect him for outperform Tex by a WIDE margin. You gotta play the market and maximize your assets. Profar is worth much more than Rizzo.

[TurdFerguson]

You gotta take your team into account. Can you win this year? If not then hold Profar. If yes then consider a trade. You do need to get more than Rizzo, but I like Rizzo and expect him for outperform Tex by a WIDE margin. You gotta play the market and maximize your assets. Profar is worth much more than Rizzo.

I completely agree with your assessment.. I just do not want to overreact and do something Ill regret.. Im playing the market but the guy just wants to do Rizzo straight up.. I doubt I could win it this year because my staff is pretty bad.. It looks like Skaggs and Shelby will start the year in the minors.. I really really like Rizzo but Im not doing it straight up for Profar.. The one team with Matt Moore was offering Justin Nicolino with him but Im not that big on Nicolino..

[kab21]

I would pass on both offers but I think now is a good time to trade Profar. I don't see plus power (HR's) or speed (SB's) from him. If it were me then I would try to target an elite youngish arm with Profar/Skaggs. It's crazy what people will trade for 'elite' prospects.

This offseason
Sano, Arcia and spare parts for Harvey (still kind of a prospect)
Myers, Skaggs, Ventura and Odor for Sale and RWeeks
Bogaerts and Heredia for the Panda
Hedges (not elite) for Perkins