Bruce/Goldschmist for Prince/Melky

[stlcards02]

20-team pts league, 8 keepers, pretty balanced scoring as you go down the tiers. Only differences in scoring is 3 for SB's and -0.5 for K's on hitters.

I'm kind of torn on this one due to my man love for Goldschmidt, can see a big year from him. So the deal would look like this:

My Bruce(735) and Goldschmidt(640) for his Fielder(799) and Melka Cabrera(648)
projected points for each guy are in ( )

C: J.Montero
1B: Encarnacion
2B: Altuve
3B: Longoria
SS: Rutledge
OF: Bruce
OF: Holliday
OF: Ellsbury
Util: A.Jones
Util: Goldschmidt

Am I just being stubborn on my players?

[kab21]

Go for Fielder. he's the best player by far.

[msing]

Melky would be my hold out. He's only had 1 good year. Prince is worth it, but he's not fitting 50 HR anymore.

[Kimbos Beard]

I like Prince but I don't want anything to do with Melky. I pass on this trade.

[bodsquad]

No melky. No one knows what he is going to produce this year. Prince vs. goldscmidht. Prince is going to get u more pts, but by how much?. Goldscmidt is a popular pick this year. He is getting picked in the top 35.

Bruce vs. melky. Not even close because melky has not been consistent and last year he was doping.

[rmessne]

I don't think I would do it. If you could squeeze a better outfielder from him instead of Melky I would though.

[MadDog36]

Stay put. Your 2 are best.

[fsbarren]

Agreed. Melky is too uncertain this season to make it worth the risk, even for Fielder at this point. If I were the other guy, I'd be ecstatic about the prospect of unloading Melky for those two guys, even if I had to give up Fielder.