Which deal is better for AGon?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

30 team dynasty league, where we each have a MLB team and 40 man rosters with prospects for the teams as well. 7x7 H2H league with Holds, QS, OBP, TB as extra cats.

I have two offer on the table for my AGon:

HIS Dan Strailey, Ryan Cook, Brian Wilson, and Justin Ruggiano for my AGon, Huston Street, Jonathan Villar.

Or

HIS Carlos Santana and Kirk Neuwenheis for MY AGon and Carlos Ruiz.

Which deal do you like better?

Here is my MLB roster:

C-Ruiz
C-Ellis
1B-Smoak
2B-Ellis
3B-Youk
SS-Rollins
MI-Furcal
CI-Hannahan
LF-Ichiro
CF-De Aza
RF-Rios
OF-AGon
OF-Crisp
U-Francisco
U-Lee
BN-Bogusevic
BN-Olivo
BN_Morel
BN-Lillibridge
BN-Downs

SP-Chacin
SP-Danks
SP-Humber
SP-Lee
SP-Kluber
RP-Street
RP-Perez
RP-Reed
RP-Horst
RP-Bailey
P-Peavy
P-Correia
P-Harang
BN-Morton
BN-Valdez
BN-Crain
BN-Miller

[MrT]

neither

[GiantsFan14]

They're both pretty terrible.

[kidsilk]

The thing is I have to cut some salary( I left out the salaries for the time being) and AGon is 12 million. Santana is only 1 million. Ok thanks guys.

[lambo1203]

If I HAD to pick one, I'd go with the second one. You're getting a cheaper catcher who will play the whole season compared to Ruiz who's gone for 1/3 of it

[OBPlover]

yeah both are pretty bad for you.

[exm]

As stated above, both deal suck. Can't you get a better deal? Out of the two the least bad option would be #2. Thanks for helping me

[nflfbjunkie]

I would have to agree. I wouldn't make either trade.

[BUCCOFAN]

don't like either....but if you really have to make a move, Option 2

[kslates]

I'd find a different way to shed some salary. Those are both awful


Help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=455870