Which Trade should i accept? need help QUICK! WHIR

[ATLbravesFan92]

Ive been offered 2 trades

The first i have been offered is Jason Heyward for My Aroldis Chapman, Middlebrooks, and Desmond Jennings

The second i have been offerred is Jason Heyward for My Wainwright and Freese

Which do you think is better for my team?
10 team h2h league

My team is:
C- Mike Napoli
1b- Eric Hosmer
2b-Howie Kendrick
3b-Miguel Cabrera
SS-Starlin Castro
CI- Will Middlebrooks
MI- Andrelton Simmons
OF- Justin Upton
OF- Jose Bautista
OF- Shin Soo Choo
OF- Alex Gordon
OF- Desmond Jennings
Util- David Freese
BN- Brett Gardner
BN-Wil Myers
BN- Alex Avila
BN- Jedd Gyorko

SP- Adam Wainwright
SP- Zack Greinke
SP- Yu Darvish
RP- Mariano Rivera
RP-Brandon League
RP- Addison Reed
P- Aroldis Chapman
P- Matt Moore
P- Jon Lester
P- CJ Wilson
BN- Jeremy Hellickson

[plamb23]

Neither really. They are both too much IMO

Maybe try Freese/Chapman or Wilson/Lester

I do like you getting rid of Freese

[MadDog36]

I think I'd just stay put in your shoes. You don't really have the pitching depth to deal Waino and the other deal meh..Your OF is fine as is and so is your team if you ask me.

The only two things you need to do: acquire a slight 2b upgrade and a closer.

Maybe Freese/Kendrick could land you a mid tier closer and a slight 2b upgrade along the lines of an Uggla or Zobrist? You can try..

By the way what is available in FA for 2b and pitching?
I see NO need to keep Avila - I would dump him.

[jtsandwich]

Pass on both, they are asking for too much.

[fsbarren]

*******MY RESPONSE FROM YOUR OTHER POST ON JUST THE FIRST OFFER*******
If you want to do it (and it does sound like you want to...with a couple of valid reasons), I'd make him swap his best closer (assuming he has a good one)for B. League. Chapman may end up closing again before too long, and League may be at risk with Jansen in the background (League lost the closer job in Seattle last season and I think he temporary lost it the season before). Just throw something like this in the counter : " If you can downgrade your closer to League, we have a deal." I'd also ask for the other player he'd drop, just to see.

You could make the deal as-is, but I think you might leaving value on the table. At the same time, you don't want to waste playable value on your bench when you can merge a couple of players into an elite one.

Another option: find whoever has Broxton and dangle Chapman as both a solid SP and Broxton's replacement and then throw in either Middlebrooks or Jennings and try to reach for someone like Heyward. The point is, I think there are still some options to explore before you sign off on that first offer. Try to work the first guy for more while shopping the pieces he wants with other owners to see if you can better (and for fewer players).
***********************************************************************************************

ON your second trade offer, I don't like that one. Keep your ace for sure.