Which Keeper? Chapman, Goldschmidt, or Kipnis?

[jdowling24]

I'm allowed two keepers in my head-to-head league. I am keeping Bryce Harper. For my second keeper slot, I am choosing between Aroldis Chapman (P), Paul Goldschmidt (1B), and Jason Kipnis (2B). Please help! Thanks!
-jdowling 24, New York, NY

[UrbanatorNation]

As a general rule I'd go hitting over pitching. So between Kipnis and Goldschmidt I'd go Kipnis. Better value at 2B and I'm guessing you'll have a shot at getting Goldschmidt back.

[Pogotheostrich]

Goldschmidt pretty easily IMO

[MadDog36]

Do you have any other option?
I'd go Kipnis on positional scarcity.

[rupertoooo]

There is no value in any of them so go with the one who can provide you with the biggest reward, Goldschmidt.

[Element]

Comes down to Goldschmidt and Kipnis. I like both quite a bit, but Goldschmidt is a little bit more projectable.

[Fenris-77]

Goldschmidt for value, and maybe Kipnis for positional shizz, but mostly Goldy.

[HOOTIE]

I like Chapman

[fsbarren]

To be honest, not knowing your league specs I wouldn't be overly thrilled with either as a second keeper, but I think Kipnis offers you the upside of a potential top-5 2B, whereas Goldy is closer to top-10 status at 1B. I really like Goldschmidt and he might be a bit more projectable as someone mentioned, but in this context I'd go with Kipnis and hope he lives up to his potential ceiling.

[Grounded Polo]

Goldschmidt pretty easily IMO