Need help with final 2 Keepers

[GerryH]

I play in a 14 team, head-to-head league in which we keep any 6 players each year.

My first 4 picks are pretty much no-brainers:

Miguel Cabrera
Joey Votto
Andrew McCutchen
Stephen Strasburg

My final 2 picks will come from a shortlist of 4:

Jason Heyward
Matt Cain
Aroldis Chapman
RA Dickey

At the moment I'm leaning toward Heyward and either Cain or Chapman. I'd expect at least a repeat of last season from Heyward, with some possible improvement. Cain is always a solid performer and Chapman will either be a slightly risky starter (although league settings include K's per 9 innings which will still be solid) or a lights out closer. Dickey is the one I'd most expect to see a dropoff from.

Thanks for any help.

[Nats 2013]

agree with cain and heyward.

[TeeBall DH]

I'd go Heyward and Cain for the reasons you stated.

RA Dickey is the risky one out these 4. No way he repeats last years numbers. He may still be a good pitcher but wont give you last year.

Chapman is a great talent but I would be worried about the transition to a starting pitcher, Chapman would have to do a lot to out pitch Cain, seems unlikely that he will.

[kidsilk]

It's a slam dunk for Heyward and Cain here without a doubt.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=454916

[HOOTIE]

Heyward
Chapman

[lane_anasazi2]

Definitely Heyward. I could see a case for any of the three pitchers, honestly. I think in a 14 team league I'd probably go pure upside and pick Chapman. There's a chance (not a big one) that he goes nuts and turns into Randy Johnson 2.0 as a starter.

[fsbarren]

Cain and Heyward, and a shout out for for the nice core you have there.

[Elsy]

Heyward and Cain for sure.