#3 Pick in Keeper League, where would you go?

[fsbarren]

Pujols
McCutchen
Fielder

Firstly, unless the rules of your league are REALLY complicated, I'd be shocked if the three guys are available. That being said, I think the consensus generally is if a top 10 player is available you grab them w/o thinking (normally, I'd recommend an SP in the 4th round, but if those guys are there you almost have to grab one of them)

If for some reason they're not available, then a top SP like Verlander or Kershaw is the way to go.

[misterf]

Can't really go wrong here with Pujols, Verlander, Kershaw or McCutchen imo. Depends on what you want to keep position-wise.

Stanton is not bad either but a notch or two below the other 4.

Beltre is a bit too old to include in the first set but is absolutely solid as well.

I would pass on Fielder at this point (worried about a drop off in a few years due to his body type) and I would want no part of Upton.

[Baseball2727]

I would probably try and get Pujols or Prince...after that, I love Cutch. Looks like a top tier arm will fall to you on way back rd. 2 so I wouldn't reach there.